Gear Diary Barnes & Nobles eBook strategy photo

I posted yesterday that Barnes and Noble announced their new eBook reader, the Nook. Today I had the opportunity to join a conference call with William Lynch, President of BarnesandNoble.com, to hear more about the Nook and Barnes and Noble’s plans for the digital media market. In addition to learning about the Nook, the question and answer portion highlighted the confusion around ebooks and where they fit into the future of bookselling.

First and foremost, the Nook. Mr. Lynch began by running through the highlights of the device: the dual screens, the LCD’s versatility, the depth of content, and the hands-on experience that will be available at every Barnes and Noble in the country. He emphasized that each bookseller will be trained on the Nook, and that displays with working units will be in every store. This is key, since the Nook’s biggest competitor (in mindshare and marketshare) is the Kindle, which most consumers are forced to purchase sight unseen.

And then the questions began to roll in, and that’s where the call got interesting. Essentially the queries fell into two broad categories: questions about the Nook, the Nook experience, Nook content, etc., versus questions about eBook strategy, eBooks in general, and where Barnes and Noble was heading with the Nook. What I found very interesting was that the latter questions seemed to heavily come from “traditional” journalists, while the Nook-specific questions came from the technology/blog world. More on that in a bit.

Onto the good stuff: the gory details about the Nook. The name apparently was chosen because it is reminiscent of the word book, because nooks are associated with bookstores and because “the URL was available”. While it runs on Android, there is no web browser and there are no plans at this time to bring out an SDK. Bad news for those overseas: even though the Nook has WiFi, you won’t be able to purchase books outside the USA.

More important than the specs of the Nook itself were the hints of what B&N has planned for the future. Currently they are offering 45 magazines and newspapers for the Nook, but they are hoping for a much larger list in the future. The “LendMe” feature, which allows you to loan a book to a friend for up to 14 days, is only available for some books right now, but they are hoping to expand that list and get more publishers on board. Refreshingly, Mr. Lynch was extremely honest and up front about the restrictions they were facing from publishing houses, though he seemed confident that some of those would ease with time and further eBook success. The biggest message that came through was that Barnes and Noble wants to do two things: drive eBook content through their online on-device storefront, and bring people into their brick and mortar stores through special features only available via the Nook and B&N wifi (like the ability to browse a whole book in-store, and they are looking at other exclusive content as well.) I did ask if the Nook would have backwards compatibility with legacy eReader/fictionwise/peanut press libraries, and while Mr. Lynch did not know the answer they will be getting back to me soon.

So then we come to the questions that, in my view, really highlighted where there was some confusion about the Nook and eBook strategies in general. There were questions about whether Barnes and Noble was becoming a technology company, the formats supported, and even someone asking the price (clearly they didn’t read the press release!) My personal favorite was: “Will you be offering other stores on the Nook”, to which Mr. Lynch replied “Why would we want to do that?”

I think that last question, about whether other stores’ content would be available on a Barnes and Noble device, really highlights where eBooks are throwing the thinking about digital media for a loop. Everyone is looking for the “iPod of books”, but that’s not where the money is; what will really determine who wins this is who has the iTunes of books. This isn’t digital music, where the iPod is an evolution from the CD player, which was in turn an evolution from the walkman. In the case of music, the content needs a compatible piece of hardware. Subtract a CD player, and your stack of CDs is worthless. So the most important piece in that relationship becomes the hardware that brings you the media. In contrast, paper books do not need a hardware component. The hundreds of paper books scattered through my house work just fine without anything having to act as interpreter in bringing me their content. So when books make the jump to eBooks, the hardware becomes secondary; I’m using a convenient tool to access my book, but the book is the key part. There was never a “walkman of eBooks” to blaze a path, and linking your content exclusively to expensive hardware is backwards. Books don’t need hardware, so pushing the hardware over the content misses the point. Provide your content across multiple devices, provide a way to keep them all in sync, and now you’re giving the consumer a compelling reason to buy into the hardware. But unlike with the iPod/CD player/Walkman paradigm, the content is king.

And Barnes and Noble is pushing their content, not their hardware. They are happy to be “content partners” with Plastic Logic and iRex, because that’s another audience that will buy books. Not everyone is going to spend $259 to have a tool to read books, but if they can get the software for free on their computer and smartphone, then the books become more attractive. Getting consumers to buy a Nook is a nice bonus, and ties them closer to B&N, but in the end, this is all about books with whatever tool you use to read. Barnes and Noble made it clear in today’s conference call they want to be the iTunes of books; it should be interesting to see if they succeed.

Tags:



Carly has been a gadget fiend for a long time, going back to her first PDA (a Palm M100). She quickly went from researching what PDA to buy to following tech news closely and keeping up with the latest and greatest stuff. She loves writing about ebooks because they combine her two favorite activities; reading anything and everything, and talking about fun new tech toys. What could be better?
  • http://firesaw.blogspot.com lloydrv

    Very interesting read. Looking forward to more information on the Nook and B&N’s strategy. Bummer there won’t be a web browser at launch; I was imagining myself reading Gear Diary on a larger screen than my iPhone. My eyesight’s not like it used to be, so bigger is better.

  • http://www.geardiary.com Michael Anderson

    Not sure I agree with the assessment of MP3 vs. eBook. Certainly since the dawn of recorded music there has been an intrinsic hardware / content dichotomy, whereas books have been more or less constant for centuries.

    But as I noted before, I am amongst those who have been reading ‘eBooks’ for nearly 20 years, and have multiple file formats and have bought from many stores. What has constantly happened is that new formats come with new DRM and won’t work with old formats and eventually the vendor drops support for the older format, and you are stuck with useless books or using a ‘crack’ tool to extract your file.

    The reason that is relevant is the non-answer regarding eReader. Maybe it is my recent experience with the Sony PSP Go and their terrible treatment of existing customers … but there is absolutely no way they couldn’t have thought about this, and therefore I assume it is their intention to screw over those of us with existing libraries of DRM-infected eReader & Fictionwise content in the hopes they can sell us the same book twice.

  • Haesslich

    Well, on the upside they’re actually ADOPTING Adobe DRM (ADEPT), which means their hardware will be able to use other stores’ encrypted ePubs as long as they comply with ADEPT requirements… assuming that B&N doesn’t screw up by introducing their own twist to ePub encryption the way they did with their current version of PDB-based books.

    As for Sony… well, they’re improving, slowly. In some areas. With some things. The eReader hardware (PRS-300, PRS-600) DOES support ADEPT DRM, and ePub, which means they can read books from non-Sony Ebook Store sites. They’re also transitioning over all the LRX-format books to ADEPT, and have promised (so far) to allow people who downloaded their books in LRX format the ability to download Adobe Digital Edition versions of the same books in ePub. Although with the current method of lending that they’ve stated they’re using (you can loan a book out to one person, but in turn lose access to it on your current device), it’s both a step forward… and a step back – on the one hand, they haven’t crippled it the way Microsoft did with their ‘social music’ on Zune (three plays of a song, or three days)… although the way they’re tying people to their own platform (I’m going to have to assume that this isn’t using Overdrive technology, which ePub already supports), which in turn suggests they’re going to go proprietary with their DRM.

    Again.

  • Pingback: Lee Benz

  • http://www.geardiary.com Carly Z

    @Lloydrv: We should have more coverage in the next few weeks too…there’s a lot still coming out about this.

    @Michael: But reading ebooks on your PDAs for years is kind of the exception, not the rule; the average B&N shopper probably didn’t know they could do that until at the earliest the iPhone, or even this week when the nook was announced. For the non-tech friendly group, books come in paper form and that’s it. But ebooks are slowly creeping into that world, and it’s content, not hardware, that is the driving force IMHO…we shall see…

    @Haesslich: I didn’t know that about the LRX—>ADEPT transition. Do you have a link to Sony’s promise to allow people to download books in ePub after they purchased in LRX? I’m guessing a lot of our readers here didn’t know that…

  • http://www.geardiary.com Michael Anderson

    @Carly – I agree with my reading on the HPLX, Newton and Psion being an exception, but by the time of the later Palm and every PocketPC device, there were stores and fully formatted books available which were bought by many thousands of folks – heck, Amazon has had eBook stores for nearly a decade.

    But my point isn’t so much to argue history, or even suggest that every reader should be required to read every format (any more than MP3 players should need to deal with multiple formats)

    … my point is that I think that B&N should recognize that they are entering a market with hardware now, but already have software and content – and therefore customers – from eReader / Fictionwise. And since many of those customers have been around for several years, I feel that B&N should have been ready with an answer about how they would support existing customers …

    … and if the answer is ‘we are not’, then we need to hold them to it, to make it clear that all of these new book readers are no better than the old MSN music, and when B&N decided to stop supporting them, all of this content will be gone – as through their actions they will have shown that they have no regard for their customers or their money. Of course, if they provide an ‘eReader import utility’ that will convert a book purchased in eReader into a book in their B&N account, then all is good :)

  • doogald

    Another difference between music (in a stack of LPs/CDs) and books is that most of us gladly, and by choice, listen to the same music over and over and over again, while most of us read most books once, and only a handful a handful of times. Having a great, portable device to carry our entire library of audio content is extremely covenient. Once you read most books, you are done with them, and there is little reason to carry them around with you, and most people are only reading a single book at a time – there is little reason to carry more than one.

    And, of course, we listen to music in the background, while we do other things – drive, pay the bills, cook and eat, relax, do chores, even while reading. On the other hand, reading is a dedicated exercise – you cannot read (well) while you are doing other things.

    This is another reason why the iPod model is not as applicable to ebook readers as people try to make them.

    As for DRM, I think it’s just the nature of the beast. There is no model like the live concert event for writers to get revenue, to use their books freely distributed to promote. The books are their revenue stream, and as long as people can steal content, they will try. If the quality if what you are reading is not as important as the inclusion of DRM, bully for you, but I am very discriminating about what I read, and it often is material that is copyrighted and valuable to its author. If I want it electronically, I’ll suffer the DRM, but know that I’m likely to read it only once anwyay, so it’s not as big a deal as music and video DRM.

  • Pingback: Kim Dockery

  • Pingback: Anton Spelec

  • Haesslich

    CarlyZ: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/08/13/sony_epub/
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/technology/8201093.stm

    And straight from the horse’s mouth:
    http://ebooks.custhelp.com/cgi-bin/ebooks.cfg/php/enduser/std_adp.php?p_faqid=133&p_created=1250171533&p_sid=l8fZB5Lj&p_accessibility=0&p_redirect=&p_lva=&p_sp=cF9zcmNoPTEmcF9zb3J0X2J5PSZwX2dyaWRzb3J0PSZwX3Jvd19jbnQ9NCw0JnBfcHJvZHM9MSw5JnBfY2F0cz0mcF9wdj0yLjkmcF9jdj0mcF9wYWdlPTEmcF9zZWFyY2hfdGV4dD1lcHVi&p_li=&p_topview=1#prevPurch

    What will happen to previous purchases from the eBook Store from Sony, or to additional purchases that occur before the conversion?

    Books that have been purchased from Sony’s eBook store in Broad Band eBook format (BBeB) will continue to work on existing devices. When the store is converted, customers will be able to re-download their previously purchased books in EPUB format.

    Current Reader owners can continue to purchase and read their BBeB eBooks in the meantime.

  • http://www.geardiary.com Carly Z

    Awesome, thanks for providing those links! I’m not terribly up on the sony store but that’s good to know!

  • http://www.geardiary.com Michael Anderson

    I also just saw on Engadget that the ‘loan’ feature is limited to a one-time EVER per book 14-day loaner … and has to be approved by the publisher. Better than nothing … but pretty severely limited.

    Saw it on the news with my wife this morning … no interest from her.

  • Haesslich

    Michael Anderson: I suspect this is what the publishers always wanted: people had to buy a book, period… and this seems to indicate that this is definitely a new DRM method, since Overdrive lets you borrow a book again and again, or loan it out again and again, with only the number of licenses being limited for simultaneous ‘loaning’.

    This is going to help sales of the Nook. Not. It might help piracy, though. :P “Want to borrow a book from a friend? PIRATE IT.”

  • Pingback: Will All Brick & Mortar Media Sink Like Blockbuster?: Tech News «

  • Pingback: The Brave New Digital World: An interview with K.C. Blake | Gear Diary



Madden NFL 25 Anniversary Edition Amazon Exclusive Deals

EA Sports, Amazon, and DirecTV have released details on great deals included in the upcoming limited-edition version of the Madden [...]

team & marke Launches Fläzbag Tablet Pillow Stand

I don’t know about you, but when I think of “products from Germany”, I think of severe stuff, by and [...]

Toddy Screensters Clean Your Screen with Character

Toddy Screensters

If you own any device with a touchscreen, then you know all too well how quickly and easily they get [...]

Zact Debuts Industry’s First Smart Mobile Service with “Never Overpay Guarantee”

As far as I’m concerned, the more choices there are out there among cell phone service providers the better.  Yes, [...]

My Roku 3 Remote Saves the Day!

Gadgets have become packed with more and more features, many of which we end up forgetting about or just never [...]

Google Announces Game Center Clone ‘Google Play Game Services’

Google Games Center

At Google I/O last week we got to see a number of new things, including the music service we already [...]