The Death of eBooks Has Been Greatly Exaggerated

10 years ago, people were predicting the physical book was dead. eBooks were the rage, and everyone was predicting Kindles and Nooks would replace physical books on our shelves, in our backpacks, and on our nightstands. Instead, the physical book launched an unexpected comeback, the Nook is dying, and eBooks are back to being a niche; but they’re not dead.

The Death of eBooks Has Been Greatly Exaggerated

Image Courtesy Bookish

I’ll start by admitting I love eBooks; I’ve used them since the early days of Palm Pilots. I will read literally anything in front of me, so having a book on hand no matter where I go is indispensable. These days, though, I hardly pay for eBooks, at least not directly. Most of my library comes from Kindle Unlimited and/or Overdrive via the public library. Kindle Unlimited is very hit or miss; it’s the ebook equivalent of browsing a used bookstore sale, where you might find crap or you might find a hidden jewel. It’s $9.99 a month, but I figure if I find 1-2 good books per month out of it, it’s worthwhile. Also, there’s a surprising number of classic and famous works available, from Lord of the Rings to Harry Potter. I’m also extremely lucky that my local library has a robust Overdrive catalog, and I’ve found that roughly 80% of the time I can find a book I want via Overdrive eBooks.

At the same time, I’ve drifted back to physical books for a lot of uses as well. I prefer a physical textbook for school, even though I could and have used my Kindle when I didn’t want to haul a giant textbook around. There’s just something about highlighting and taking physical notes that make recall easier. In addition, there’s nothing quite like wandering a bookstore, where you don’t have a plan and you can just browse what looks intriguing. No matter how refined websites become, it feels different to randomly walk a store than to scroll through endless online catalogs.

This contemplation of my reading habits was triggered by an opinion piece over at Good eReader, where they opined that eBooks are on the decline. They aren’t totally wrong-Barnes and Noble’s own numbers show how precipitously the Nook business fell over 80% in a four-year span. And physical book sales are seeing an uptick across the board. But this doesn’t mean eBooks are dead. It means the novelty has worn off, and eBooks are finding their place in the pantheon of ways to read. It used to be that a reader’s options for books were hardcover, trade paperback, and mass market; hardcover was priciest, followed by trade paper and then mass market. The price decrease usually also came with a portability improvement, since a mass market paperback is much easier to slip into a pocket or bag than a hardcover. eBooks turned all that around and upside down; the traditional wait time/portability balance between a hardcover new release and a paperback didn’t matter as much when you could toss 100 books on your Kindle or phone and go.

The concept of digitizing books also came after music and movies had their very mainstream shift from physical media to streaming and downloading, and it felt on the surface like this was the next big step. But the difference between a book and a DVD is that the DVD required an extra device and steps right from the start. You can’t pick up a DVD and watch it without using a device to read the DVD, plus a television or monitor to watch the content. So streaming a movie instead just eliminated the part where you inserted the disk; it swapped and streamlined the hardware requirements but the basic outline was still the same. Books are different; you don’t need anything extra to read a book, so eBooks almost performed the opposite of what streaming did for other media. Digital books ADDED steps and complications instead of eliminating them. Add in the pricing drama that went on behind the scenes for years, and the shift from tablets/eReaders/phones to phablets, and it becomes clearer why the novelty of a book on your phone wore off in favor of the simplicity of the tried and true printed word.

However, eBooks still have their place. They make sense as a portable solution, and they work phenomenally well as library books if, like me, you constantly forget to go back to the library and suddenly the “free” library book cost you $20 in fines. It’s best to see the eBook as a cousin to the printed book, akin to audiobooks. They are a niche, one that fills a specific need but isn’t for everyone. There’s plenty of room in the publishing world for all these formats to exist in harmony, without the expectation that one market or another must shift entirely digital to survive.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. If you are shopping on Amazon anyway, buying from our links gives Gear Diary a small commission.

About the Author

Zek has been a gadget fiend for a long time, going back to their first PDA (a Palm M100). They quickly went from researching what PDA to buy to following tech news closely and keeping up with the latest and greatest stuff. They love writing about ebooks because they combine their two favorite activities; reading anything and everything, and talking about fun new tech toys. What could be better?

3 Comments on "The Death of eBooks Has Been Greatly Exaggerated"

  1. Peter Schott | March 14, 2019 at 1:42 pm |

    Some books really make more sense in paper format. The latest spate of Graphic Novel Adventures (like a choose-your-own adventure comic book) doesn’t work as well for e-readers until they figure out how to link panes to other panes properly. Trying to “flip” to the right page otherwise doesn’t work.

    Some books I’d love to have in ebook format just aren’t available that way.

    For plain reading for enjoyment or tech books, I’ll usually opt for an e-book of some sort. They don’t take up shelf space. I can carry them with me. Tech books get outdated quickly so the cheaper/smaller option is really useful there – as is the ability to search and copy/paste code snippets easily.

    However, I can still get a paperback cheaper than some ebooks so there’s a lot to be said for them. We hit the library pretty regularly and they just added an “auto-renew” service so as long as the book isn’t on hold/recalled and we’re currently active, the books are renewed up to 10 times (up to 20 weeks). That’s pretty cool. They also offer some digital checkout items, though the selection is still a little limited.

  2. I have also been a ‘forever fan’ of ebooks, and loved that people have taken it on themselves to transcribe text to digital files since … well, at least the late 80s that I have known. And my first ‘portable device’, the ~1991 HP200LX, was able to store and let me read books in text format, which was awesome.

    So I have no desire for physical books – but I am alone in my house having that opinion! Personally I am glad that both exist … I just hope that we manage to keep our local B&N open!

  3. Proprietary closed-source parties have all but murdered this medium. (I mean, their bastardizations of EPUB, and their locked-down “ecosystems” of device/rendering engine).

    You literally have to buy one of each e-Ink device (well over $100 apiece). And publishers (big and small) must specially cater to, by which I of course mean extensively modify the coding for, these bastardizations of the erstwhile standard EPUB format (because the same XHTML/CSS/JS will not render as it ought to on all of them if left as-is; which is the point of their having done this). The obvious nasty consequence of which: they cost more than they ought to (not infrequently more than their physical/real counterpart in print), because of overhead for doing it not once, but several times, is immense.

    Additionally, there is actually still not enough standardization of the EPUB format itself, too… (for instance, media queries, such as having a universal means of telling any device/app that you’re in “dark mode” or “light mode”… so that you can actually code that media query into the eBook’s CSS to thereby have specified a different background and foreground color, so on… oh no, they all have their own often undisclosed means to that end… because there is no actual standard media query for this… and a fair few other things. Ugh!).

    For those of us willing to still bother with eBooks, you pretty much have to settle for a mere tablet and a few apps… (eh, well… those of us not liquid enough to sink over a grand into XYZ proprietary devices). Until or unless some true blue philanthropist comes out with an affordable tablet albeit with an e-Ink screen, there is no happy medium in way of A device that can do it all. *Sigh*

    And so far, since 2019, I have found a grand total of one app/rendering engine that actually does render everything I require (e.g. webkit, special characters like non-breaking space, etc.): PocketBook Reader. All the rest have problems faithfully rendering the code as it was intended, or else aren’t maintained/in development anymore. It’s sad.

Comments are closed.