Image courtesy of GeekyGadgets
By now you have likely heard that Apple did a refresh on the Mac Mini, greatly overhauling the internal and external hardware and enhancing the overall specifications … and the price. The basics are as expected – more or less a copy of the 13″ Macbook Pro with more desktop-like set of connectors. The big new features include the addition of a HDMI port, upgrade of the graphics chip, and the sleek new look.
Here are some details:
Most notable is the new aluminum unibody enclosure, which stands just 1.4″ tall and features an easy-to-access memory panel. Other new features include an HDMI output, NVIDIA GeForce 320M on-board graphics, and Secure Digital card slot.
The base Apple Mac mini costs $699 and features an Intel Core 2 Duo 2.4GHz dual-core processor, 2GB RAM, 320GB hard drive, SuperDrive, AirPort Extreme (802.11a/n wireless), Bluetooth 2.1+EDR, Gigabit Ethernet, and OS X 10.6 Snow Leopard.
I loved the look and basic feature set, and since my 2008 15″ Macbook Pro is pretty much stationary these days I thought about grabbing one of these and passing along the MBP.
Then I started looking at the price! It felt like car shopping – I started out at $600 but by the time my configuration was done I had topped $2000!
OK, just for comparison sake I tried the same thing with a 13″ Macbook Pro and an iMac 27″. So let me break down how I compared:
Base 13″ Macbook Pro
- 13.3″ screen
- 2.4GHz Core 2 Duo
- 4GB RAM
- 320GB Hard Disk
- Integrated nVidia 320 graphics with 256MB shared memory
- Slot-loading 8x Superdrive
- Integrated mouse and keyboard
- No other options
- Price: $1249
Base 21.5″ iMac
- 21.5″ screen
- 3.06GHz Core 2 Duo
- 4GB RAM
- 500GB Hard Disk
- Integrated nVidia 9400M graphics with 256MB shared memory
- Slot-loading 8x Superdrive
- Included Magic Mouse and wireless keyboard
- No other options
- Price: $1199
Base 27″ iMac
- 27″ screen
- 3.06GHz Core 2 Duo
- 4GB RAM
- 1TB (1000GB) Hard Disk
- ATI Radeon HD 4670 graphics with 256MB of GDDR3 memory
- Slot-loading 8x Superdrive
- Included Magic Mouse and wireless keyboard
- No other options
- Price: $1699
Base Mac Mini
- No screen *
- 2.4GHz Core 2 Duo
- 4GB RAM
- 320GB Hard Disk
- Integrated nVidia 320 graphics with 256MB shared memory
- Slot-loading 8x Superdrive
- Added Magic Mouse and wireless keyboard
- No other options
- Price: $937
* Adding the cheapest Apple monitor raises the price of the Mac Mini to almost $1850!
So for $150 less than a Mac mini with a 24″ monitor you can get a 27″ iMac with more storage, a more powerful processor and a MUCH better graphics solution. Perhaps the better comparison is with the 13″ Macbook Pro, since you are getting nearly the same computer, and could add a 3rd party 22″ widescreen monitor – even one with HDMI – for less than the $300 price difference. And if you already have Bluetooth peripherals then you save even more – removing them from the above configuration drops it to $799.
Still I have to ask – am I alone in thinking that the Mac Mini, the system Apple seems to be pushing as a budget system, is even more of a ’boutique PC’ than their other offerings? Was I misguided thinking there was a solid value proposition choosing the Mac Mini over a Macbook Pro?
What do you think? Do you have a Mac Mini or plan to get one? How do you feel the value compares to other Apple offerings?
I sincerely hope that no one getting a Mac Mini is buying an Apple Monitor with it. Their monitors are notoriously over-priced.
I think Apple is still mainly offering it for people who already have a monitor and keyboard and such, and therefore can avoid some of those extra costs. It is still the low*est* cost entry to having a Mac, but it does seem to be slipping on price appeal, even as it improves on specs and design. Love the new all aluminum enclosure and the now built-in power supply.
I think over time it has closed some of the performance gap that previously existed between it and other Macs, so it should be pretty decent machine for a desktop for most typical uses. I would still recommend an iMac where possible, though, but it all depends on budget. If you already have peripherals and monitor, than the mini is the cheapest option hands down. “Value” is something that is also dependent on your needs, too. If a laptop is useful/worth it/desired, then yes, a 13″ MacBook Pro is probably a good buy.
I’ve read that it’s a great deal when you use it as a server.
I want one! I’d hook it up to one of my TVs, use a wireless keyboard and mouse and not need a monitor. Seems like a far better “Apple TV” then the one I had before.
I plan on getting one now that they’ve refreshed them. We need a new desktop and I think the iMacs are overpriced. I’ll get one with a Mighty Mouse and a wireless keyboard and get an HDTV or HD monitor that can be hooked up to our satellite dish and then I can get rid of the giant old TV in our office. I’ll upgrade the RAM myself so that will be cheaper. I bet the Mini + a nice little 24″ monitor or TV will run me at least the same as the iMac if not less.
fabsgwu: I don’t know about it being a good deal as a server, though it does make a very space efficient server. HP has fabulously priced entry level servers–you can get quite decent server grade hardware in a micro-ATX tower for under $500! (well, you won’t get dual redundant power supplies in these–those cost $300-500 by themselves!)