Should the New York City Marathon Be Cancelled?

Gear Diary is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Click here to learn More.

Should the New York City Marathon Be Cancelled? Listen to this article
Should the New York City Marathon Be Cancelled?

Sunday is the New York City Marathon. This is a huge event, with 40,000 runners, several thousand volunteers, and countless spectators. Unfortunately, New York was hit extremely hard by Hurricane Sandy, and many runners are unable to make it to the city, or facing difficulties with hotel rooms, transportation, and logistics. Despite the devastation, the mayor of New York and New York Road Runners want the race to continue…but many are wondering if it’s worthwhile!’s editor Mario Fraoli had a great editorial on why the marathon shouldn’t be run at the tail end of such a disastrous week:

New York is a city that has a proven history of encountering tragedy only to unite and overcome it, even under the gravest of situations. I have no doubt that they’ll do so again during these trying times, but staging a marathon this weekend — even the biggest and most recognizable one in the world — while the city it runs through is in the direst of straits, shouldn’t be a priority, and does very little to improve the current situation for many of the 8 million plus people who call the Big Apple home. I’m ready to be ripped apart for what I’m about to write, but the New York City Marathon does not need to happen this Sunday. There are more pressing issues that rightfully deserve the city’s attention, energy and limited resources.

Electing to cancel an event of this magnitude is not an easy decision by any stretch, and some would even argue advisable or conscionable, but given the current situation in the city it’s a difficult one that must be made for the greater good of New York City and its residents. Period. While there’s a lot at stake here for marathon organizers, athletes, sponsors, vendors, and various others involved with the event, there’s even more at stake for the thousands of people who are still without power, forced out of their homes, can’t get out of their homes or otherwise waiting for assistance to get their lives back in order. As it stands, there are a limited number of public resources such as policeman, firemen and paramedics available to aid the recovery effort, and every single one of them absolutely needs to go toward helping the folks who pay tax dollars to take advantage of them, not to a race that will pay those very same resources to shut down roads and ensure that an event goes off without a hitch.

There have been arguments that hosting the event this weekend will be a much-needed boost to the economy and help increase morale in the city, but given that far less than the anticipated 47,000 runners will actually make it to the event, and those that do will be spending less time (and money) in the city because of travel delays, that dollar amount won’t be nearly what it would be under ordinary circumstances. Runners will always unite and foster an encouraging spirit for one another, especially during trying times, but this showing of support will do little for the millions of folks who will still be dealing with this tragedy well after the masses leave on Sunday night or Monday morning.

I encourage you to put yourself in the shoes of my friend John Volpe, a resident of Hoboken, New Jersey currently stranded in San Diego due to travel cancellations, who is trying to get back to the east coast before the weekend. He told me earlier today that his wife, who is stuck in their house, “has not showered since Monday. We have no power or food to prepare and I have not slept well since then.”

Mario’s whole editorial is worth reading, as I think he does a great job of addressing the pros and cons of pulling off such a difficult cancellation at the last minute.

Personally, I have a hard time wrapping my head around the event moving forwards. The president of Staten Island has said he doesn’t think they are ready to accommodate the race start, and there is a perception that the race will be pulling resources away from rebuilding efforts in the city. The truth is, even if the race isn’t pulling resources, if it feels that way, it will impact NYRR events in the future. It just feels a bit wrong to say, “it’s business as usual”, while homes are still evacuated, flooded, and/or without power.

On the other hand, I’m not running the race, and if NYRR, the city’s office, and the police and paramedics believe they can handle the race, no one else’s opinion really matters. And it’s the NEW YORK CITY MARATHON, so I doubt any decisions made this year will hurt their future enrolments either way!

What’s your take? Is it a bad idea to try to pull the marathon together, or should it continue, hurricanes be damned?

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Thanks for your support!

About the Author

Zek has been a gadget fiend for a long time, going back to their first PDA (a Palm M100). They quickly went from researching what PDA to buy to following tech news closely and keeping up with the latest and greatest stuff. They love writing about ebooks because they combine their two favorite activities; reading anything and everything, and talking about fun new tech toys. What could be better?